I'm Not That Girl — Cynthia Erivo Lyrics

"I'm Not That Girl" is a song from the musical "Wicked," performed by Cynthia Erivo for the 2024 film adaptation. Here are the key details:

• Track 8 on "Wicked: The Soundtrack"


• Released on November 22, 2024


• Produced by Stephen Schwartz, Stephen Oremus, and Greg Wells


• Written by Stephen Schwartz

The song explores Elphaba's feelings as she realizes her growing attraction to Prince Fiyero, who has shown some interest in her despite his relationship with Galinda. Elphaba reflects on the impossibility of their romance, acknowledging that she's not the type of girl who typically wins the affection of someone like Fiyero.

Key themes in the song include:

• Unrequited love


• Self-doubt and insecurity


• Acceptance of reality versus fantasy

The song serves as a poignant moment in the story, revealing Elphaba's vulnerable side and her struggle with her feelings for Fiyero. It contrasts her practical nature with her longing for a different reality, ultimately showcasing her resignation to the fact that she's "not that girl" who gets the fairy tale ending.

This version, performed by Cynthia Erivo, is a cover of the original Broadway version sung by Idina Menzel.

The 2024 version of "I'm Not That Girl," performed by Cynthia Erivo, features several differences compared to the original musical version sung by Idina Menzel. Here are the key distinctions:

Lyrical Changes

• Phrasing and Word Choice: While the core themes remain intact, some phrases may be altered for clarity or emotional impact. The new version may emphasize Elphaba's feelings of inadequacy and longing in a slightly different way.

Vocal Interpretation

• Performance Style: Cynthia Erivo brings her unique vocal style to the song, which may differ from Menzel's interpretation. Erivo's powerful and emotive delivery can provide a fresh perspective on Elphaba's character and her feelings of unrequited love.

Emotional Tone

• Depth of Emotion: The 2024 version might explore deeper emotional nuances, reflecting contemporary sensibilities about love and self-acceptance. Erivo's performance could evoke a different emotional response compared to the original.

Contextual Elements

• Character Dynamics: The interaction between Elphaba and other characters, such as Galinda and Fiyero, may be portrayed with more emphasis on their relationships in the film adaptation, potentially altering how the song is perceived within the story's context.

Overall, these differences contribute to a new interpretation of "I'm Not That Girl," making it resonate with both longtime fans of "Wicked" and new audiences while still honoring the original's themes of longing and self-doubt.